Sippican Cottage

Close this search box.
starch factory maine 1280x720


A Man Who Has Nothing In Particular To Recommend Him Discusses All Sorts of Subjects at Random as Though He Knew Everything

Hurray For Capitana Spalding

My Intertunnel friend Gagdad Bob at One Cosmos, who’s the love child of St. Thomas Aquinas and Norm Crosby, sent me this video. It’s cool for a lot of reasons.

There’s a man-bites-dog aspect to the proceedings, of course. Wispy girl plays upright bass. It’s unusual. The bass is a great big thing, and many men’s hands and most women’s are too small to comfortably play them. A regular bass neck is 34 inches long. A guitar is around 25 inches with the same number of frets, and the bass doesn’t have frets all the time. The strings on a bass are very thick compared to a guitar. It’s kind of athletic to fret a bass. Bass manufacturers started offering short-scale basses to accommodate people with smaller hands, but they didn’t catch on much. They’re still pretty big.

It’s hard as hell to sing while you’re playing the bass. Playing the guitar and singing is easy compared to the bass. Guitar playing as accompaniment to singing usually boils down to brain-stem-level motions — chord shapes long committed to memory and rhythmic strumming that’s no more complicated than tapping your foot. Bass playing’s different. You’re usually playing a kind of melody, and a kind of rhythmic counterpoint, too. I have to think about what I’m doing all the time to play anything but the most rudimentary thing on the bass while singing. There was a reason James Jamerson didn’t sing.

I’m not alone in that. Listen to Paul McCartney play the bass while he’s singing. He often resorts to playing a tuba part, more or less, so he can concentrate on what he’s singing. Fhum, fhoom, fhum, fhoom, umpa, oompa. Not very many people can play one melody while singing another. People get very impressed when they hear George Benson sing the same notes he’s playing on the guitar during a solo, but it’s the easiest thing to do other than keeping your mouth shut entirely. What Esperanza Spalding is doing is hard to do.

Really good musicians can let it rip at two things at the same time. It’s a higher form of mathematical thinking than the average person can even understand. It’s a gift to begin with, and then that gift must be cultivated to the nth degree on top of it to stand out.

In a way, Esperanza Spalding is playing trite things. There’s no cutting edge in there exactly. She is working at a very high level covering ground that’s already been broken by others. But sometimes the only way to be unusual is to be worse than what came before you. Isn’t it enough to stand on the shoulders of giants, and belong there? She does.

6 Responses

  1. In an interview in the sidebar, she mentions that her aspiration is to develop complete freedom of the hand in conjunction with complete freedom of the voice. To the uninitiated — that would be me — she looks like she already has it. It's not really the type of jazz I typically listen to, but it's hard to imagine a more perfect "ambassador of jazz." Like Louis Armstrong before her, she is just so full of life, joy, and charisma. Also, like Armstrong, she seems to have totally transcended the circumstances of her so-called "class." I wonder how many potentially talented lives are wasted as a result of assimilating the hopeless doctrines of the left, whereby one's destiny is fixed by the circumstances of race, class, and economics?

  2. One the George Benson hummin' the tune note, presenting Mr. Slam Stewart doing the same on upright:

    He cheats a little because he bows his bass during the solo, but it's still pretty impressive b/c it's totally off the cuff and improvised. The backstory on that recording is that Stewart & Byas, the tenor player, were the only members of the band who showed up on time for the concert. So they went out and put on a show. Them was professionals.

  3. I believe Glen Campbell toured with the Beach Boys playing the bass and singing the top line of the vocal harmony but citation needed as they say.

  4. yes, to your post. I'm hoping her songwriting eventually catches up with her talent as a noodler/singer.

  5. I dunno, I sometimes think Norah Jones and Diana Krall have more goin' on since they're synchopatin' two hands while they're singing…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Thanks for commenting! Everyone's first comment is held for moderation.